Ex-CMS Basketball Player’s NCAA Lawsuit Threatens the DIII Athletics Model

A former Claremont-Mudd-Scripps basketball player and two other Division III athletes sued the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) on Oct. 23 for its ban on Division III athletic scholarships, alleging a violation of US antitrust laws. The lawsuit, however, ignores the value of non-monetary benefits that the DIII model brings to student-athletes and jeopardizes DIII institutions’ commitment to the dual academic-athletic model.
Printz v. NCAA specifically challenges NCAA Division III Bylaw 15.01.3, which states that member institutions “shall not award financial aid to any student on the basis of athletics leadership, ability, participation, or performance.” The lawsuit alleges this policy violates US antitrust laws under Section I of the Sherman Act. The lawsuit describes DIII as “ a written horizontal agreement among competing buyers of athletic labor to fix the price of that labor at zero.” It further claims that the fruit of DIII student-athletes’ labor (“the revenue it produces, the attention it draws, the enrollment it yields, and the loyalty it cultivates”) goes unrewarded by institutions. As such, DIII member institutions act as a “cartel” that colludes to control the price of athletic labor and restricts the redistribution of these benefits back to student-athletes.
The case largely rests on the precedents set by National Collegiate Athletic Association v. Alston (2021), and several other antitrust cases against the NCAA collectively described as the House settlement (2025). In the Alston decision, the Supreme Court found that the NCAA could not limit education-related compensation of DI athletes. In the House settlement, the NCAA agreed to allow DI schools to directly pay athletes for their participation beyond academic-related compensation. The settlement, which individual DI institutions could opt in or out of, also replaced a rule that had limited the number of athletic scholarships an institution could distribute with roster size caps.
As these cases were specifically filed against NCAA DI, the Alston and House rulings did not carry over to DII or DIII (the DII athletes have always been eligible for athletic scholarships). However, these students are still eligible to receive compensation for the use of their name, image, or likeness (NIL), after the NCAA changed its regulations in 2021 to allow all student-athletes, regardless of division, to profit from these deals. Student-athletes can now be paid for endorsements, social media posts, and public appearances without losing their athletic eligibility.
While the legal validity of the Printz lawsuit is open to question (data shows that DIII athletic programs regularly operate at a loss, unlike DI—a key understanding that led to the House settlement), it certainly challenges the validity of the DIII philosophy and its regulation against athletic scholarships. Here, I strongly concur with a TSL opinion piece that argued earlier this month for the merit of the scholarship-free DIII experience.
The piece touches on the benefits of having an NCAA division where the student experience comes before the athlete experience. Among the rules designed to prioritize academic success, DIII prohibits student-athletes from missing regularly scheduled class time for practice activity such as lifts, film sessions, and regular practice. This forces coaches to accommodate student-athletes’ academics, rather than the other way around.
This unique feature of DIII athletics ensures that we get as much out of our education as our non-athlete peers. Athletics bolsters our college experience instead of being its defining factor. For DI and DII student-athletes, their inflexible athletic schedules come at the expense of their education.
For example, the NCAA’s 2026 GOALS study reports that 74% of male and 56% of female DI student-athletes spend as much or more time on athletics than on academics. Compare that to DIII: only 55% of male and 35% of female athletes report the same time imbalance. DI and DII students on athletic scholarships face a unique pressure that partly explains this phenomenon—their sport is their job. Their place on campus is earned through athletic success, and they are thus incentivized to value athletic commitments over academic ones.
Another argument the TSL opinion piece makes is that athletic scholarships are financially unsustainable for smaller DIII schools. While this is true, the article misrepresents the lawsuit’s proposal: it would not “mandate” DIII schools to offer athletic scholarships. Rather, it allows these schools the opportunity to offer them.
Athletic scholarships would still be detrimental to many small DIII schools, but not exactly in the way the author describes. Rather, it would throw DIII out of balance by favoring larger, more financially sound DIII schools that are able to offer athletic scholarships, forcing smaller schools to choose to prioritize either athletics or academics. These smaller schools, which often rely on full-paying student-athletes to fund their operations, could lose athletes to larger programs if they fail to offer athletic scholarships.
Our very own Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (SCIAC) offers an early warning to this type of polarization. Due to decreasing revenue, Occidental was forced to cut their football team, ending one of the longest running college football rivalries with Pomona-Pitzer and decreasing the overall quality of the SCIAC. If DIII allowed athletic scholarships, Occidental would be just one of many schools forced to make this choice. A decline in the dual athletic-academic success DIII schools pride themselves on would defeat the purpose of the DIII model.
Another positive benefit of the DIII model is less pressure to perform to an unreasonable standard. While DIII student-athletes compete at high levels, our performance doesn't dictate our scholarship packages and ultimately, our ability to remain at our institution. On the other hand, in DI and DII programs, athletic scholarships are contractually renewed on a year-by-year basis. While a student-athlete cannot lose their scholarship in the middle of the year, coaches are free to re-evaluate scholarship packages at the end of the year. If an athlete’s performance is not up to par, their aid, and possibly their future at the institution, come into jeopardy.
In the lawsuit, Connor Printz, the former CMS basketball player, and his co-plantiffs argue that they should receive damages from the NCAA based on the amount they would have gotten in athletic scholarships. However, looking at Printz’s athletic performance at CMS ironically reinforces the argument against DIII athletic scholarships.
The lawsuit details Printz's high school athletic accolades, assuming that his athletic prestige as an eighteen-year-old would have allotted him a certain amount of athletic scholarship from Claremont McKenna. However, it fails to mention his collegiate performance: as a sophomore, Printz averaged only 4.2 minutes and 1.1 points per game, while in his junior season, he averaged 4.6 minutes and 1.4 points per game. (His freshman season was cancelled due to COVID, and he quit before his senior season to pursue social media, which netted him $50,000 in NIL deals.)
While Printz may have added some other intangible benefit to team culture, the cutthroat nature of athletic scholarships prioritize performance above all else. Had Printz been awarded an athletic scholarship upon entering CMS, it may very well have been reduced or completely eliminated in the following years due to his poor performance on the court. This in turn may have affected his ability to attend CMC and remain on the CMS basketball team. Because of DIII regulations, however, Printz did not have to rely on his athletic prowess to remain a student at the school and an athlete on the team.
Printz et al. need to take their DI mindset out of DIII. It risks players’ athletic and academic futures and poses a danger to the integrity of DIII colleges.
.png)



Comments