top of page

Celebrating Thirty Years of Truth and Excellence

6 minutes ago
7 min read

This month 30 years ago, the Claremont Independent was born. A print run of a few hundred copies, hand assembled and distributed by a staff numbering fewer than a dozen, began a tradition of against-the-grain commentary and news coverage which, to its founders’ surprise—and its detractors’ dismay—continues today.


“We didn’t know if it would last this long,” recalls co-founder Ashwin Navin, “it was such a rag-tag operation.” As a freshman at Claremont McKenna College, Navin and his friends found the existing student-press scene—then dominated by The Student Life, The Collage, and The Forum—to be ideologically one-sided, poorly executed, and outright boring. 


A year later, determined to create an alternative, Navin spoke to conservative faculty at CMC and Pomona. He discovered that there had been one only a few years before from 1989 to 1991: “The Claremont Independent.” Navin consulted with legendary Pomona professor Fred Sontag, who had been associated with the old “folkloric” CI, but found there was little to build off of. 


“We started from scratch,” says Navin, who designed the original logo and defined the paper’s purpose of “maintaining truth and excellence.” Navin and co-founder Christopher Skinnell paid for the first editions out-of-pocket, bonding with early staff writers over long hours shoving thousands of folded 11-by-17 inch sheets of paper together, then leaving them at the entrance of every Claremont Colleges dorm.


“Free Thought is Back!” reads the Independent’s first headline. In a letter from the editors which would set the tone for the paper’s future, Navin and Skinnel were blunt about their goals and beliefs: “Why do we have to put up with the liberal trash that Claremont student newspapers publish? We no longer have to. We present to you the Claremont Independent.”


Volume I, Issue 1 contained a “conservative guide” to California’s Ballot propositions, an opinion piece with the subtitle “The minimum wage is an assault on the property rights of Americans,” and a full page photo of “the Gipper” (Ronald Reagan) toasting to America’s “eternal light,” among other conservative opinion pieces.


The reactions came in before the first edition had even been published. As the nascent paper began recruiting writers, The Collage (a now defunct publication) printed a story on the attempts to begin a “right-wing paper.” 


“A third of CMCers were indifferent, and another third were against the paper,” says Navin, who used the Rose Institute’s phone bank after hours to conduct surveys of the student body. “Everyone said CMC is a right wing institution, but the data showed it wasn’t,” he recalls. “We forced the narratives to be a little more honest.”


Issue 2 contained a letter from the Independent’s third co-founder, L. John Nelson IV. A year above Skinnell and Navin, Nelson served as editor at large in fall ‘96 while he completed a semester in Washington D.C..


“The Claremont Independent: A Prospectus,” offered a slightly toned down but still tongue-in-cheek rendition of the paper’s founding principles. “The New York Times and Washington Post are, of course, deeply disturbed by this challenge to their liberal heterodoxy, for they realize that this emerging journalistic force emanating from the parochial foothills of the San Gabriel Mountains will be their downfall,” Nelson wrote.


He continues, in a more serious tone, to describe in some detail the progressive excesses of the Claremont Colleges and the danger posed to CMC by the infiltration of “silliness” from Pitzer and the other colleges, arguing that the Independent could only be effective as a Consortium-wide paper.


“The success of publications like the Dartmouth Review and the Harvard Salient has been based upon exposing liberal hypocrisy and feeble-mindedness,” Nelson concluded. “I believe that the Claremont Independent’s success in the future will also be based upon such strategies, and I believe that we will do quite well in this endeavor.”


Still paying for printing costs out-of-pocket, the founders turned to conservative faculty members for support. But it was a surprise visit from CMC’s founding trustee that ensured the Independent’s early survival. “Whenever Don McKenna was on campus, John Faranda would bring him around to the more conservative events,” says Navin. “We gave [McKenna] a few copies and explained what we were trying to do, and he cut us our first real check.”


With a solid financial base, the Independent continued into a second and third volume, marking a year of successful publication. As the paper matured, its incisive, often facetious commentary became focused on Claremont itself, and—more importantly, in Navin’s opinion—was joined by investigative news pieces.


These early examples of what would become the Independent's defining strength included surveys on the faculty’s political beliefs and an article detailing a Scripps professor’s decision to screen an art-film to her class consisting “entirely of scenes of fish swimming around interlaced with lesbian sex scenes,” starring the professor and her girlfriend.


Meanwhile, the opinion section became relevant not only to Claremont’s conservative minority. One now-ironic opinion piece from Volume III, Issue 1 titled “A Modern Day Standard Oil?” criticizes the lack of on-campus alternatives to the monopolistic Huntley Book Store, and ends by encouraging students to check out the up-and-coming new online alternative, amazon.com. (The present Editorial Board only wishes that our 1997 predecessors had added some Amazon stock to the CI endowment along with their endorsement.)


Maybe CI staff make better investors than writers…
Maybe CI staff make better investors than writers…

By fall 1999, as its founders graduated, the Independent continued to develop along the lines set out by Nelson three years earlier. The Volume 6, Issue 1 masthead features dedicated bureaus for CMC, Pomona, and Scripps. The issue included an interview with then-incoming CMC President Pamela Gann, followed by a critical news piece on her inauguration. “The speech was quite long, delaying the barbecue that followed, and putting many faculty members to sleep (watching professors nod off did keep most of the audience coherent.)” It also featured pieces on alternative dining options, Ath speakers, diversity training, and internet freedom.


The September 2002 issue paid tribute to the one year anniversary of 9/11.
The September 2002 issue paid tribute to the one year anniversary of 9/11.

The Independent continued printing through the next decade, covering campus reactions to the 2001 and 2008 financial crashes, 9/11, and Obama’s election. The front and back pages gained color, the Independent formally adopting a bright red accent which has matured over the years into today’s refined “Truth & Excellence Red.”


Many copies of the Independent’s print edition featured a humorous back-page. In this article, the CI satirically critiques a sexist “Masturbation Week” at Pomona.
Many copies of the Independent’s print edition featured a humorous back-page. In this article, the CI satirically critiques a sexist “Masturbation Week” at Pomona.

As the digital age began at the turn of the last decade, the Independent began to grow its online presence. In 2013, it printed its last monthly issue and went fully online. Alec Sweet, Pomona alum and co-editor in chief from 2018 to 2020 called the years that followed, “the Independent’s Golden Age.”


In 2014, the Independent began to attract readers from outside of the Claremont Colleges. Claremont had become a flashpoint for campus speech and cancel culture issues, and the paper’s online platform sent the news well beyond the Claremont bubble and into national publications.


Matthew Reade, Sweet’s predecessor, joined the Independent as a sophomore after meeting a CI member at an event about the 2016 primaries. “They found two of the three conservative students at Pomona and put us on this panel together,” Reade recalls. Freshman year, he had put a quote by conservative black economist Thomas Sowell on his dorm room door whiteboard. A few days later someone replaced it with “bigot.”


Reade and Sweet would go on to write for and eventually lead the Independent through the 2016 election, the “surreal” campus reactions, and the years that followed. Sweet recalls wandering around Pomona on election night as students burned American flags and the series of vigils and “healing” circles that followed.


The drama didn’t stop. “We were really busy all four years,” says Sweet. The Independent covered a “no-whites” pool party at Scripps, the BDS campaign at Pitzer, and in 2017, the Independent extensively covered the protest of Heather Mac Donald's Athenaeum talk. Many stories reached the national stage, and at one time, the Independent was the second-most followed student paper on Facebook, behind only the Harvard Crimson.


The extra attention only made the Independent’s critics on campus angrier and more determined to get the paper and its staff “cancelled.” 


But Reade, Sweet, and their colleagues welcomed the backlash. “If you didn’t care, it was a really liberating thing,” says Reade. “We were a minority on campus, constantly being tested. The cacophony of critics forced us to make our writing and everything we were doing better.”


“Pressure makes diamonds,” he reflects. “We weren’t diamonds, but the pressure certainly made us better than a lot of folks on the other side, who didn’t have to develop that rigor because they surrounded themselves with people they agreed with.”


They also discovered over time that Independent was not as unpopular as it seemed. “I came to find the longer I was at the CI the more people would come up to me, people I didn’t expect, saying ‘I don't agree with what you guys write but I’m really glad that you’re doing it,’” recalls Reade.


The rigor helped them in the long run too. Sweet, Reade, and many of their peers are now successful lawyers, as are Skinnell and Nelson. Navin went the entrepreneurial route, co-founding BitTorrent and then Samba TV.


In 2018, changes to the Facebook algorithm began to curb the Independent’s online reach. Then came the Covid-19 pandemic, and, as the Claremont Colleges only became more progressive, fewer and fewer conservative, centrist, and right-of-center students existed to fill its staff.


The Independent’s commitment to truth and excellence never faltered, though. In 2022, the Independent broke the story that CMC had attempted to punish professor Christopher Nadon for his use of the n-word while quoting from The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn in a class. The story spawned dueling op-eds in the Wall Street Journal and attracted national attention. And the Independent’s 2024 Christmas album gave Mariah Carey a run for her money. “It is still regarded by many as one of the most important miscal recordings in American history,” says then editor in chief, Trevor Klein.


When Claremont descended into Boycott, Divest, Sanction mania in the wake of the October 7 attacks in 2023, a new generation of Claremont students skeptical of the mob mentality sweeping its way through the Consortium made the Independent their home. 


The Independent's staff connects with founder Ashwin Navin last spring.
The Independent's staff connects with founder Ashwin Navin last spring.

News coverage of campus protests, swatting incidents, academic drama, and higher-ed M&A have continued to bring the Independent into national and even international publications. Commentary on “anti-racist” writing pedagogy, student (mis)interpretations of formal attire, hypocritical commencement speakers, Pomona’s failure to welcome conservative viewpoints, and other issues continues to provide a counter-weight to the Claremont Colleges’ progressive hive-mind, and a voice to ideas unwelcome in Claremont. 


Most importantly, the Independent remains just that: Independent. The CI receives no funding from the Claremont Colleges or their student governments, making us the only actually independent student press on campus. Through the generosity of private donors—like Donald McKenna himself—the Independent continues to deliver on its founding promise: upholding Truth and Excellence at the Claremont Colleges.


So having looked back, with much gratitude for those who came before us, let us look forward to the next 30 years of the Claremont Independent.


If you’d like to support the Independent’s mission of maintaining Truth & Excellence at the Claremont Colleges, please consider making a tax-deductible donation to our 30th anniversary fundraising campaign here.


Comments


Founded in 1996, The Claremont Independent is the only fully independent student publication at the Claremont Colleges.

41829_Claremont Independent_LOGO_SP_PB-02.png

Explore

  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Copyright © 2026 The Claremont Independent.
All rights reserved.

bottom of page