top of page

When the Motley Chooses Its Flags, It Chooses to Ignore Title VI

4 minutes ago
3 min read
Image by author.
Image by author.

On November 13, the Motley Coffeehouse announced that its “walls look different today.” A November 10 email from Scripps College administration gave the student-run coffeehouse two options: display American and Israeli flags alongside its prominent Palestinian flag, or remove its flag displays altogether. The Motley chose the latter, with 90 percent of staff voting to remove the Palestinian and Ukrainian flags rather than display symbols they believe conflict with their mission.


The Palestinian flag has become a symbol of solidarity, resistance, and liberation for many students, but for others, it represents the opposite. The flag caused controversy in 2024, when Scripps shut down the Motley after its staff refused to take down Palestinian flags following a similar request from Jewish and Israeli students to hang an Israeli and American flag. The Motley’s efforts to create a welcoming space for students matter. That is why in both 2024 and this semester, students did not request that the Palestinian flag be removed.


Instead, their requests suggested the addition of Israeli or American flags alongside the Palestinian flag so that they could see their identities and values represented too.

The Motley's own decorations policy states that its staff is committed to celebrating the “diverse identities and experiences of our community.” It further prioritizes representation for marginalized groups, including people of color, LGBTQ+ individuals, refugees and people with disabilities.


These are admirable goals. But if the Motley truly values diversity, it should recognize that diversity extends beyond race, gender and sexuality. It also includes nationality, religion, political beliefs and the ability to engage with people whose perspectives challenge our own.


Scripps students took to the Motley’s comment section to attack the college. “@scrippscollege is that desperate to fly the iSSraeli flag?” one asked. But the college’s legal obligations are clear. Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits discrimination based on national origin at colleges that receive federal funding. One metric for Title VI compliance is whether the college’s environment is hostile to students in any protected category. Because the Motley is owned by Scripps, failure to comply with the Title VI could invite repercussions on the College.


It’s not hard to imagine that Jewish and Israeli students might feel that the prominent display of a Palestinian flag—and no Israeli flag—at the heart of campus makes Scripps an unwelcoming environment. Scripps is still under investigation for violations of Title VI; do students expect their college to risk violating federal civil rights law and losing federal funding?


Many commenters pointed out that Scripps took issue with the Palestinian flag, but not explicitly the Ukrainian flag. The commenters ignore that Scripps gave the option to display additional flags or  “have no flag displays at all.” Why? Because, again, national origin is a Title VI protected category. A Russian student could make the same claims of a hostile environment if the Motley refused to fly the Russian flag upon request. That’s why the Scripps administration's request was simple: either fly all the national flags anyone asks for, or none. 


But Title VI aside, if a college-owned coffeehouse is going to celebrate political identities and perspectives, why should its walls reflect only those its staff agrees with? Colleges—including social spaces they own—should be places of free inquiry, where different beliefs and ideas can interact with each other. I may disagree with the positions many students choose to champion, but I recognize that the ability to express those disagreements is an extraordinary feature of American democracy.


The American flag does not represent unconditional support for every action of the American government. It represents, among other things, a constitutional tradition in which citizens are entitled to challenge that very government, express their beliefs, and even fly a Palestinian flag.


Israel, too, has competitive elections, an independent press, and a long tradition of political demonstrations, including protests against its own government, which is certainly not beyond criticism. And the Palestinian flag doesn’t represent the misdeeds of Hamas or Fatah. Its flag can represent a people's identity and aspirations without endorsing every action of their political leaders—and so can Israel’s and America’s.


The Motley staff may genuinely believe that displaying an American or Israeli flag conflicts with their mission. As individuals, they are entitled to those beliefs. But they ultimately answer to Scripps College, an institution with Title VI obligations and a commitment to inclusivity for people of all nationalities.

Founded in 1996, The Claremont Independent is the only fully independent student publication at the Claremont Colleges.

41829_Claremont Independent_LOGO_SP_PB-02.png

Explore

  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Copyright © 2026 The Claremont Independent.
All rights reserved.

bottom of page